The all-time top 10

#GameMetascoreYear
1Grand Theft Auto VI992026
2The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time991998
3SoulCalibur (Dreamcast)981999
4Super Mario Galaxy 2972010
5Grand Theft Auto IV982008
6Super Mario Galaxy972007
7Grand Theft Auto V972013
8The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild972017
9Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3972001
10Perfect Dark972000

Rockstar's Red Dead Redemption 2 (97) held #10 until GTA 6's launch knocked it off the list. Three of the top 10 are now Rockstar games.

Why GTA 6 ranks above Ocarina

Both games sit at a 99 Metascore, but GTA 6's comes from ~150 critic reviews versus Ocarina of Time's 22 - a far larger consensus, which is why most trackers now list GTA 6 first. It also means GTA 6's score can still drift as late reviews arrive.

FAQ

What is the highest rated game on Metacritic?

Grand Theft Auto VI at 99 - technically tied with Ocarina of Time's 99 but ranked first on review volume.

How many 99-rated games are there?

Two: GTA 6 and Zelda: Ocarina of Time. SoulCalibur sits just behind at 98.

Has any game scored 100 on Metacritic?

No - 99 is the ceiling so far for a Metascore (individual critics give 100s, but the aggregate never reached 100).