Consensus read: the Anaheim Ducks own the top spot on nearly every list (Mighty Ducks throwback done right), with Buffalo, Washington, Pittsburgh and Carolina filling out the top tier. The Chicago Blackhawks and Vegas Golden Knights are the most divisive — some lists bottom them out entirely.

The tier list

S = instant classic, A = strong, B = solid but safe, C = forgettable, D = back to the drawing board.

TierTeamWhy it lands there
SAnaheim DucksGreen/purple/gold Mighty Ducks nostalgia with the flying-V sleeves and an "Orange County" stitch — top-3 on essentially every list
SBuffalo SabresThe goathead returns with a red-eyed crest and metallic gold — a throwback remix fans actually wanted
SWashington CapitalsCapitol Dome crest, screaming eagle shoulders, marble yoke — peak Ovechkin-era nostalgia timed perfectly
SPittsburgh PenguinsAndy Warhol pop-art penguin in light blue — the boldest swing in the set and the #1 pick on some lists
SCarolina HurricanesStormy the Ice Hog finally gets the spotlight — personality the franchise needed
ANashville PredatorsFull country-music stage wear — filigree detailing everywhere; the most committed theme in the collection
AToronto Maple Leafs100 years of franchise logos on the hem, arched wordmark — classy tribute, held back by loud sleeve striping
ALos Angeles KingsPurple returns, Hollywood lettering, palm trees on the sleeves, six diamonds for six decades
ACalgary FlamesRed and gold kept simple; the gold hem shaped like the Saddledome roof is the detail that sells it
AFlorida PanthersDivisive coral sunrise beach-shirt look — top-10 on one list, bottom-5 on another; we land on "bold enough to work"
BColumbus Blue JacketsGrey base with oversized "Arch City" sleeve striping — a real idea, not just a recolor
BNew York IslandersThe infamous Fisherman crest returns cleaned up — a rehabilitation, not a repeat
BSeattle KrakenAnchor centerpiece with rhododendron hem — safe, nautical, could've pushed the palette further
BWinnipeg JetsNorthern lights gradient sleeves — great concept, middling execution
BSan Jose SharksScuba blue and shark-teeth striping, undercut by an oversized SJ crest
BVegas Golden KnightsThe single most divisive jersey — casino felt, roulette sleeves and card-suit numbers; #10 on one list, dead last on another
BMontreal CanadiensTradition-heavy as expected; dignified, safe, unlikely to offend or thrill anyone
CMinnesota WildDark base with one pop of color — a pattern shared by most of the bottom half
CPhiladelphia FlyersLiberty Bell and Philly history theme in grey — idea over execution
COttawa SenatorsDark and one-note; a missed chance on a franchise with room to experiment
CVancouver CanucksSkyline and waterfront inspiration that reads as "blue that does nothing"
CColorado AvalancheMuted take that doesn't leverage the state's landscape as much as it could
CSt. Louis BluesClean but indistinct — gets lost in the mid-pack with Tampa
CTampa Bay LightningAnother blue jersey that could belong to anyone
CDetroit Red WingsMinimal deviation from the classic look — Motor City deserved more
CNew Jersey DevilsDark base, single accent — forgettable
DBoston BruinsLate-20s on most lists — uninspired for an Original Six brand
DNew York RangersSurprisingly bland for a franchise with this much iconography to mine
DDallas StarsNear the bottom on consensus — flat and forgettable
DUtah MammothA blue jersey for the league's newest team was an anticlimax — flagged as a flop on multiple lists
DEdmonton OilersBottom-three material — dark base, no story
DChicago BlackhawksDead last on the Sportsnet ranking: a green sweater for a team whose color isn't green; thrift-store bound, though a minority defends it
Method note: this is a consolidated view, not one outlet's order — we averaged the Sportsnet, theScore, ColorWay and Sporting News rankings (they disagreed wildly on Vegas, Florida and Chicago). Ranking jerseys is inherently subjective; your mileage will vary by team allegiance.

About the collection

FAQ

What is the best Hometown Remix jersey?

The Anaheim Ducks' Mighty Ducks throwback tops most media rankings, with the Sabres, Capitals, Penguins and Hurricanes rounding out the consensus top five.

What is the worst Hometown Remix jersey?

The Blackhawks' green design is last on Sportsnet's list and widely mocked — though the Vegas casino jersey splits opinion hardest, going from top-10 to dead last depending on who you ask.

When did the Hometown Remix jerseys come out?

All 32 were revealed November 2, 2026, and teams wear them in scheduled home games this season.

Can I make my own Hometown Remix tier list?

Yes — tier-list maker sites got templates with all 32 jerseys within days of the reveal, which is what most people searching this term are looking for.