TL;DR: the disappointment is mostly about launch friction, not the game itself - crashes and lost-progress reports on PS5, the 212GB download, the $79.99 price, no PC version, and a code-in-a-box with no disc.

The main complaints trending

What the praise side says

For balance - the other half of launch-day Reddit is the opposite: the map's scale, Jason and Lucia's chemistry, the Mandy scene going viral within hours, and review scores (99 Metacritic, dual 10/10s from IGN and GameSpot) framing it as a generational release. Most "disappointment" threads are about access friction on day one, not the game's quality.

FAQ

Why are people disappointed with GTA 6?

Mostly launch friction: crash/lost-progress reports on PS5, the huge download, the higher price, no PC version, and a disc-less boxed edition.

Is GTA 6 actually good?

By reviews, yes - 99 on Metacritic, the highest-rated game of all time at launch. The complaints are about the launch experience, not the game.

Did Rockstar fix the crash issues?

No official word as of launch day - patch 01.002.001 shipped pre-launch; a day-one patch hasn't been announced.