ⓘ

Best overall: the Man Catcher (+5 Str, +2 Def, no downside, bonus crit) - Insane Store / Snow Store in Insane Mode or the Blacksmith Pack DLC. Runner-up is the NG Golden Sword (+5 Str, +5 Mag, -3 Agi) for 1,300 gold at the Insane Store.

How weapon stats work

Stat / EffectWhat it does
StrengthMelee damage - your bread and butter
MagicSpell power and mana pool
DefenseDamage taken
AgilityMovement speed and arrow speed
Critical Strike4x damage on a proc - great for bosses, weaker than flat Str for clearing mobs
Ice / Poison / Fire / ElectricityElemental proc chances - nice bonuses, not build-makers

Best weapons

WeaponStatsWhere to get it
Man Catcher+5 Str, +2 Def + critSnow Store (Insane) / Blacksmith Pack DLC
NG Golden Sword+5 Str, +5 Mag, -3 AgiInsane Store, 1,300 gold
Gold Skull Mace+3 Str, 4% critDrop / store
Chainsaw+5 Def, 5% critDrop / store
Butcher Knife+5 Str, +2 Agi, -2 Mag400 gold, normal mode
Ribeye+4 Str, +4 Agi, -2 MagWall-mounted in the Ice Castle
NG Lollipop+2 Mag, +5 AgiEarly-game store favorite for agility builds

Where weapons come from

Level drops

Weapons sit in chests, on walls and on enemies all through the campaign - grab everything once.

Stores

Castle Keep, Snow Store and the Insane Store sell the strongest gear for gold.

Character unlocks

Beating the game with a knight unlocks his weapon for the rest of your roster.

DLC

Packs like Blacksmith and Pink Knight add exclusive weapons.

The Weapons Frog

Every weapon you've touched lives at the Blacksmith's frog - swap and compare stats there anytime.

Insane mode

The top-tier picks are Insane-gated - beat the story once to unlock the mode and the store.

FAQ

Crit or Strength?

Strength for everyday clearing - crit is best saved for single-target boss fights where each proc lands on one health bar.

Do remastered stats differ from the originals?

Yes - Steam/Remastered reorganized groups and rebalanced several weapons, so old Xbox-era lists can be off by a point or a tier.

Best early weapon?

Whatever has the highest Strength you've found - the Meat Tenderizer (+2 Str) from Thieves' Forest is a classic early grab.